On Thursday, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton filed a lawsuit against the Biden administration regarding the federal contraception program that offers birth control to teenagers without parental consent. The Title X program has been the sole means for minors in Texas to obtain confidential contraception. However, a court ruling in 2022 mandated that Texas providers must obtain parental approval.
Here’s what you need to know
Title X is a program that originated during the Nixon era and offers confidential contraception to all individuals, regardless of their income, immigration status, or age. It has been established through federal regulations and multiple court rulings that Title X providers are not permitted to mandate teenagers to acquire parental permission for receiving birth control.
Back in 2020, a father from Amarillo made headlines by suing over a provision that he claimed violated his parental rights under the Texas Constitution. Represented by the well-known conservative legal figure, Jonathan Mitchell, who formerly served as Texas Solicitor General, Alexander Deanda filed a lawsuit in federal court located in Amarillo. It’s worth noting that Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk, who is known for his conservative views, is the primary judge who presides over almost all cases in this court.
In March, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Kacsmaryk’s ruling, which required Title X providers in Texas to ask for parental consent before prescribing birth control. Kacsmaryk and Deanda were both in agreement on this decision.
The year 2021 saw the Biden administration introduce a new regulation that highlighted the fact that Title X providers cannot demand the permission of parents or guardians for giving services to minors. Additionally, no staff working on Title X projects can inform a parent or guardian before or after a minor has asked for or obtained Title X family planning services.
According to Paxton, the reason for Texas suing is that the rule goes against the judgment made by the 5th Circuit. He strongly believes that the rule is unacceptable and is requesting the courts to impose a permanent injunction against it.
In a statement, Paxton criticized the Biden Administration for its attempt to compel healthcare providers in Texas to provide contraceptives to minors without parental consent. He accused the administration of going to extreme lengths to push its agenda, even at the cost of flouting the Constitution and breaking the law.
The lawsuit filed by Paxton has been submitted to federal court in Amarillo, which means that it will be heard by Kacsmaryk. It’s worth noting that Kacsmaryk has previously ruled against the program’s confidentiality clause.
According to Title X providers, maintaining confidentiality is essential, especially when working with minors who may not be in a safe position to seek parental permission for birth control. However, Every Body Texas, the administrator of the Title X program, has not yet responded to a request for comment on the matter.
According to Dr. Luis Garza, chief medical officer of Project Vida, an El Paso-based Title X provider, there was a significant decline of 50% in teen appointments for contraception after the implementation of parental consent requirement. This was reported by The Texas Tribune in April.
Garza stated that many individuals are hesitant to participate because they fear their parents will discover their involvement, resulting in them losing out on valuable opportunities.
Impact on access to reproductive health care in Texas: While this lawsuit does not affect access to contraception for teenagers in Texas as Title X providers in the state already require parental consent, it is a part of a larger trend that restricts access to reproductive health care in Texas.
According to recent fertility data from 2022, Texas has experienced a rise in teen pregnancies for the first time in decades. This increase coincides with the state’s decision to ban almost all abortions after six weeks of pregnancy. With the lack of access to contraception and the virtual ban on abortions, healthcare providers and advocates are concerned that the number of teen pregnancies will continue to rise.
According to Dr. Josephine Porter, chief medical officer at Tyler Family Circle of Care, teenagers who are unable to obtain parental consent for birth control are often overlooked by the healthcare system until they become pregnant or contract an STD. These teens are typically invisible to the system, which highlights the need for increased access to birth control for minors.
Read More:
- Arizona Humane Society Waives Adoption Fees for Large-Breed Dogs
- Arizona home inspector posts videos online; One builder files complaint